BBC On The Record - Broadcast: 19.03.00

Film: LOCAL ELECTIONS VT The local elections take place in May. Will they show that Tony Blair cannot take the result of the General Election for granted.



JOHN HUMPHRYS: The Tories are feeling relatively pleased with themselves this weekend. They reckon they've got the government on the run over a number of different issues and they've just scored their first by-election victory in Scotland for more than thirty years. The next big test for all the parties is the local government elections in England and Wales in the first week in May. Labour's worry is that many of their traditional supporters will stay at home and the Liberal Democrats are afraid they may continue to lose voters in the south. All of which would be good news for the Tories and people may start saying that Tony Blair cannot take the General Election for granted. Terry Dignan has been taking some soundings of his own. TERRY DIGNAN: For nearly twenty years the high tide of Conservatism dashed Labour's attempts to capture the towns of the Medway. Then, in 1997, the Conservatives were swept away. Now they hope to show they're on course to winning back the Medway towns by taking the council from Labour in May's local elections. What the Tories are counting on is a little help from Labour's core supporters. If Labour's traditional core vote fails to turn out here in the Medway towns and the rest of England, the Conservatives could be heading for their best election result since 1992. Like Labour, the Liberal Democrats are also worried. Although they expect to make gains at Labour's expense in the urban North of England, they fear losing to the Tories in their Southern strongholds. The big question mark hanging over the Conservatives is whether they do well enough in these local elections to suggest they pose a serious threat to Labour at the General Election. Hoo St Werburgh is a microcosm of England's electoral battleground and, says Medway's Labour leader, could provide clues for the General Election. PAUL GODWIN: Well, this is an ex-council housing estate which has been taken over by a local housing society. A lot of core Labour voters here who would have voted for us in '97 in a marginal ward and obviously we need to ensure they come out again and vote for us on May the Fourth. We currently have one Labour councillor and one Conservative councillor representing this ward so it's extremely important. We returned three Labour MPs in Medway at the '97 General Election and, of course, this is a testing time for us in terms of the vote at the local elections, probably a year, eighteen months in advance of the next General Election. I know the three local MPs are working very hard to help us get the Labour vote out in the local elections for that reason. So it is going to be a clear indicator and pointer to what might happen in the General Election. PROFESSOR COLIN RALLINGS: Labour core supporters exist everywhere - there are of course many more of them in the North of England and in parts of urban Scotland, but even in the South there are pockets of strong Labour support and if Labour supporters there are taking the same attitude to the party and to the Government as Labour supporters in the North and in Scotland, then it can have a similarly damaging effect. DIGNAN: So worried is Medway Council about future turnouts, it's hired a drama group to persuade these bemused sixth formers that voting is cool. Low turnouts don't hurt every party. It's being predicted that if Labour voters stay at home in May, the Conservatives can feel optimistic about regaining Medway's Parliamentary seats at the General Election. RODNEY CHAMBERS: If the traditional Labour core vote stays at home, then it is my belief - and I think it will stay at home - that the three Members of Parliament, Labour Members of Parliament, that are representing the Medway towns at the moment, must be very seriously worried people. DIGNAN: When the parties cast off and set sail for polling day, how many of their supporters will climb aboard? In local by-elections Labour has only been able to retain sixty-eight per cent of the votes it received at a previous council contest. The Conservatives, though, have kept ninety-four per cent of their vote; the Liberal Democrats ninety per cent. So low turn-outs in council elections have been hitting Labour hardest. RALLINGS: In London and in other places, councils for example like Medway, there are pockets of very strong Labour support; and if those Labour supporters sit at home then it means, at the elections in May in Medway, that it could have the effect of Labour losing effective control of the council. And of course if they sat at home again come the General Election, then it would mean a seat like Gillingham, part of the Medway Towns, would be taken back by the Conservatives from Labour with almost no votes actually changing hands. DIGNAN: The early signs of Spring in Kent. Yet Labour fears many of its core supporters feel their lives show little sign of changing for the better under Tony Blair's Government. GODWIN: I think it is of concern. I mean, obviously, the national opinion polls are still very favourable to the Labour Party but I think it is a problem for us. I think any party in power when they're governing clearly has to get across what it's achieved. And the Labour Government's no different from anybody else. DIGNAN: Nowadays local politics generate little excitement. But that doesn't put off Liberal Democrats like Maureen Ruparel. At the last Medway elections her party won as many seats as the Conservatives. To improve the Tories chances of winning the council - and then the Parliamentary constituencies - they need to take votes off the Liberal Democrats. It's conceded that may happen albeit on a limited scale. MAUREEN RUPERAL: Apart from people switching to the Liberal Democrats, I think an awful lot switched to Labour at the last election. Some may go back to the Conservatives if that's their natural home, but basic core Liberal Democrat support doesn't alter. DIGNAN: During the nineties that support rose steeply in Torbay. So much so that the Liberal Democrats won control of the Devon resort from the Tories on the back of the Poll Tax revolt. Since then they've also won the area's Parliamentary seat. The recent history of voting behaviour here in Torbay will be familiar to many parts of Southern England. First, the Liberal Democrats win control of the council. Then, they oust the sitting Conservative MP. To show they're well on the way to reversing this process, the Conservatives in places like Torbay will have to be able to inflict heavy losses on the Liberal Democrats in these elections. Glassblowing - a craft practised at Cockington Court with funding from Torbay Council, whose leader is visiting. She's up against Conservatives who - no longer associated with an unpopular Tory Government - find it easier to exploit local discontents. ANN WIILIAMS: There are difficult decisions that we have to take locally, not just here in Torbay, nationally. Government legislation has to be adhered to, and our local Conservatives here are in an extremely comfortable position. How wonderful to be able to criticise the Labour government. How wonderful to be able to criticise the Liberal Democrat administration. DIGNAN: In areas like Torbay the Liberal Democrats believe they've benefited from tactical voting. It's meant Labour supporters backing them to defeat the Conservatives. But now the Conservatives are out of office, is tactical voting much in evidence? WILLIAMS: I don't think the Labour supporters here in Torbay would like to see a Conservative MP, or a Conservative council. A lot of people that I speak to on a regular basis, they don't forget the Tory days here in Torbay. It's commonly known, many, for many, many years as Tory Bay." RALLINGS: I think the case has now rather changed, and the Government isn't hugely unpopular and neither any longer are the Conservatives. At the next time if people revert to their normal party pattern, then that may allow, in several of the constituencies, the Conservatives to slip through the middle without actually polling many more votes than they did last time. DIGNAN: These are the Conservative activists who stayed loyal during the years of unpopular Tory rule. Driven from power throughout the South West, they're planning a comeback. Today they're delivering newsletters denouncing their arch enemies in the region, the Liberal Democrats. RICHARD CUMING: I think the tide is turning against them, I think if you have a look at the European election results twelve months ago, the Conservatives in the Bay polled over nine thousand votes, the Liberal Democrats just over three thousands votes. The message is clear that people aren't prepared to support the Liberal Democrat policies either locally or of course nationally. DIGNAN: Yet even if the Liberals Democrats do lose seats in the South, that won't tell the whole story. Because they could be making gains at Labour's expense in the urban North. RALLINGS: During the 1990s when the Conservatives were so unpopular the Liberal Democrats took many seats and indeed Councils, from the Conservatives, especially in south and south-west England, places like here in Torbay. And they've found their success now over the last couple of years more in traditional Labour areas where they can compete effectively against Labour Councils and represent a protest vote against the Labour government. DIGNAN: Having once looked as if they might sink without trace in local elections, the Conservatives are back afloat and charting a course to possible victory. In council by-elections their share of the vote is running at thirty-six per cent, ahead of Labour at thirty-five per cent. Lying astern are the Liberal Democrats - their vote share is currently twenty-four per cent. Projecting these figures to May gives the Conservatives about three hundred gains. Labour would make roughly two hundred and eighty losses with the Liberal Democrats showing little or no change - suggesting they'll do well in Labour's Northern heartlands but badly at the hands of the Conservatives in the South of England. So what do these calculations tell us about Liberal Democrat prospects at the General Election? Winning in the North may not be of much comfort to them because there are few marginal Parliamentary seats they can gain there. It's the South which will determine their immediate future. RALLINGS: Almost half the Liberal Democrat seats currently in Parliament are at risk to a five per cent swing from them to the Conservatives at the next General Election; and their performance in parts of the south suggest that they are now suffering that level of swing to the Conservatives - that must put some twenty of their MPs under serious threat. DIGNAN: But does the scale of the Conservatives' predicted gains - three hundred extra council seats - mean William Hague could defeat Labour at the General Election? RALLINGS: I think in reality these elections in the coming May, the Conservatives need to register something in excess of four hundred gains to suggest they have the kind of lead over Labour at this stage in the Parliament which they could use to build on to threaten the Labour majority at the coming General Election. DIGNAN: May will see the start of Torbay's summer season. By then we might only be a year away from Tony Blair calling a General Election. Much could depend on Labour avoiding a poor performance in the local elections. That means persuading core supporters it's worth joining the one in three people who now bother to turn out.
NB. This transcript was typed from a transcription unit recording and not copied from an original script. Because of the possibility of mis-hearing and the difficulty, in some cases, of identifying individual speakers, the BBC cannot vouch for its accuracy.