===================================================================================
NB. THIS TRANSCRIPT WAS TYPED FROM A TRANSCRIPTION UNIT RECORDING AND NOT COPIED FROM AN
ORIGINAL SCRIPT; BECAUSE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF MIS-HEARING AND THE DIFFICULTY, IN SOME CASES,
OF IDENTIFYING INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS, THE BBC CANNOT VOUCH FOR ITS ACCURACY
....................................................................................
ON THE RECORD
TONY LLOYD INTERVIEW
RECORDED FROM TRANSMISSION: BBC ONE DATE: 2.5.99
....................................................................................
JOHN HUMPHRYS: Well I spoke to the Foreign Office Minister
Tony Lloyd a little earlier this morning and I began by asking him whether there would be a
diplomatic response from NATO to today�s release of the three American servicemen.
TONY LLOYD: That�s a very welcome development but actually
it�s not that positive a development, I mean, how do I explain for example to all the Kosovo
Albanian refugees in Macedonia and Albania and in different parts of the world that it was
only on the basis of these three individuals that NATO had to respond. Milosevic knows
what he has to do. He has to make sure there�s a secure environment for the Kosovo
Albanians to return to and that means withdrawal of his troops and it means an international
peace keeping force and when he comes to negotiate on that basis then that will be progress.
HUMPHRYS: So nothing in response to that and nothing in
response to what the Russians have been trying to sort out themselves, they�ve been
beavering away trying to get some sort of diplomatic solution that hasn�t been acceptable to
us. It seems that we�re not actually interested in negotiations, all we want effectively, is a
total surrender from Milosevic on those five points that have been made to him.
LLOYD: Well I think terms like whether this is total
surrender, not interested in negotiation, are rather loaded. Of course ��
HUMPHRYS: �.But this is reality, isn�t it?
LLOYD: Well, we are interested in negotiation because in
the end Mr. Milosevic knows he will have to negotiate a proper solution, but there can�t
seriously be any compromise on the Kosovo Albanians returning home with enough security
to guarantee they don�t get killed. That�s not something anybody would negotiate on. I mean,
I must put it to all of your listeners, would anybody seriously go back to Kosovo at the
moment with Milosevic�s army there, without a proper NATO led force to guarantee long
term security because I am certain I wouldn�t.
HUMPHRYS: So to return to my basic point, that is it. Unless
he concedes those five points no negotiations clearly and we just keep bombing and bombing
and bombing.
LLOYD: Well most certainly until Milosevic understands
he must concede on those five points then there can�t be any end to the conflict that he�s
started because of course let�s also be realistic, he still continues to do enormous damage to the
ordinary people in Kosovo. That�s why those five demands are not matters of NATO being
unreasonable autocratic, it�s actually what are the very basic reasons for NATO taking action
in the first place, not just military action, it�s why for a year we tried a diplomatic solution.
Milosevic at no stage has been prepared to create a framework that gives the Kosovo
Albanians the opportunity to live in peace and without the kind of fear of death that they
have lived with over recent weeks or months.
HUMPHRYS: So Kofi Annan of the United Nations and Victor
Chernomyrdin from Russia, Jesse Jackson for that matter, all of whom have been talking to
him in one way or another, they might as well all pack up and go home?
LLOYD: No, we very much welcome the role of all
credible mediators and certainly both the Secretary General of the United Nations and Mr.
Chernomyrdin on behalf of the Russians are very welcome as mediators. In the end there will
have to be mediation, but Milosevic has got to understand that mediation is possible but only
if he�s prepared to give basic and well understood pre-conditions and that is the five demands
that NATO has already put forward. We have got to see the Albanian refugees return to their
homes. We�ve got to see them return with long term and short term security. Not so
unreasonable.
HUMPHRYS: So the only mediation to use your word comes
after he has surrendered. You don�t like the word surrender but that�s what it amounts to
isn�t it?
LLOYD: Well I am not sure the word is relevant in this
context. Mr. Milosevic knows that he can�t continue to make war against his own people if
he�s got to surrender to the Kosovo Albanians and say that I won�t make war against my
people any more, then that�s surrender but these are ��..
HUMPHRYS: �..He�s got to do more than that hasn�t he?
He�s got to pull all of his forces out of his own country, he�s got to allow armed forces into
his country, if that isn�t surrender, heaven knows what is.
LLOYD: But those are the necessary preconditions for us
and most importantly the refugees to know that they can return to their homes from which
they were driven at gunpoint by Milosevic. Now, the terminology really doesn�t matter as
long as we are all very clear that Milosevic has got to conform to those demands.
HUMPHRYS: That�s the point. And we can never now, can
we, sit down at a table with him, because we have so demonised him - we�ve called him a
genocidal murderer and so on, so talking to Milosevic, I mean, you for instance, or one of your
colleagues, Tony Blair or anybody else for that matter sitting down at the table and talking
with Milosevic simply isn�t on is it? Can�t be done.
LLOYD: Well Mr. Milosevic I understand said yesterday
he would like to meet President Bill Clinton.
HUMPHRYS: Is that on the cards?
LLOYD: Well that�s Mr. Milosevic who issued that
comment and of course in the end Milosevic himself has demonised himself, it�s Milosevic
who has turned his murder machine against innocent people in Kosovo, it wasn�t NATO, it
wasn�t Britain. Within that context of course, we will talk to Mr. Milosevic, but on the basis
that he wants to make a proper and long term arrangement for the return of the refugees and
their security when they return to their homes.
HUMPHRYS: It�s a bit obvious isn�t it? I mean, people like
your own Foreign Secretary, Secretary of State for Defence come onto programmes like this
and talk about him as a genocidal killer. You can say no worse of any man than that can you?
The idea that you would actually sit down with a genocidal killer and talk about anything is
bizarre, isn�t it.
LLOYD: Well this is rather, damned if we don�t, damned if
we do isn�t it? We are intransigence if we refuse to talk. We are compromisers if we do talk.
But the simple reality is ���
HUMPHRYS: I�m saying you�ve painted yourselves into a
corner, that�s my point.
LLOYD: No, there�s no corner into which we are painted.
Mr Milosevic continues to push himself into that corner but our objectives are very very
clear: We want to see the refugees return. Now in the end of course Milosevic, I suppose,
does know that he has to accept NATO�s preconditions, the question for us is how long is it
going to be before he accepts that as the basis on which he operates? Within that of course we
will arrange for talks to take place that allow the refugees to return, there�s no compromise in
doing that, no compromise with a recognition that Milosevic has turned what is a machine of
murder on civilians of Kosovo.
HUMPHRYS: So if�. When you say�. If he does accept all
this and the refuges go back to Kosovo it is inconceivable isn�t it that he could still be in charge
of Kosovo, after all they would hardly go back with a genocidal killer in charge of the country,
you wouldn�t want them to go back with a genocidal killer in charge of the country so that�s
out isn�t it?
LLOYD: Well I think that is the practical reality where
Milosevic now has driven things but that�s been his choice and that�s been the result of his
actions.
HUMPHRYS: So we have to unseat him?
LLOYD: Well what we�ve begun to talk about of course is
the idea that there should be some form of international control of Kosovo to allow a political
structure to exist when the refuges are beginning to return and have returned so that that can
move forward the ordinary day to day life, to rebuild the police force, to rebuild the school
system, to rebuild the economy. All that�s going to need some form of civil authority but it is
true to say that Mr Milosevic has made it almost impossible now for the Kosovan Albanians
and maybe even the Serbs to accept his long term control in Kosovo.
HUMPHRYS: So de facto independence for Kosovo, that�s
what we�re talking about?
LLOYD: I think we�re talking about some form of
internationalisation of the civilian control for Kosovo with a view obviously that the long term
future, as we always said, can be defined once we�ve got to a more stable Kosovo and refuges
returned and are able once again to play the part of citizens of Kosovo and not refuges in
different parts of the world.
HUMPHRYS: We are fighting this war we are always told, we
were told right from the very beginning for moral reasons. Doesn�t morality demand that we
increase the diplomatic efforts one way or the other, seriously negotiate one way or the other
even if it means a bit of compromise because the longer this goes on every single day it goes on
innocent people are being hurt, they are being killed, you say they are being raped. Terrible
things are happening to an awful lot of innocent people every day this war goes on. We�re
seeing more NATO bombs going astray and killing people in a �bus. We can�t just carry on
like this can we?
LLOYD: No. I think there is nobody on the NATO side
who wouldn�t want to see the military phase come to an end forthwith but the control of that
d does rest I�m afraid with Mr Milosevic.
HUMPHRYS: That was the Foreign Office Minister Tony
Lloyd.
.....ooooOOoooo....
4
FoLdEd
|