NB: THIS TRANSCRIPT WAS TYPED FROM A TRANSCRIPTION UNIT RECORDING AND NOT
COPIED FROM AN ORIGINAL SCRIPT: BECAUSE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF MIS-HEARING AND
THE DIFFICULTY, IN SOME CASES, OF IDENTIFYNG INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS, THE BBC
CANNOT VOUCH FOR ITS ACCURACY.
...............................................................................
ON THE RECORD
PADDY ASHDOWN INTERVIEW
RECORDED FROM TRANSMISSION: BBC-1 DATE: 01.11.92
...............................................................................
JONATHAN DIMBLEBY: Paddy Ashdown, let's get it clear. You
intend to recommend to your Party that on Wednesday night it should vote to
support the Government in this motion?
PADDY ASHDOWN, MP: I intend to recommend to my colleagues
and, so far as I can tell, all of them will agree with it - that we intend to
vote in favour of Britain's future in Europe. The Government's future is not
at issue in this. Britain's future in Europe is. I do not intend to indulge
in the kind of disreputable, tawdry decei
in by asking people to vote for something last April, which I now vote against
in October.
DIMBLEBY: And that means that the wording, as it
stands, despite its anodyne quality, suits your purpose - it's enough for you?
ASHDOWN: Well, I think we can claim a victory in
this. We have forced Mr. Major to face up to the issue and the last sentence
in the wording asks the House of Commons to do exactly what I asked Mr. Major
to to (I've asked him for three or four months) - stop hiding behind the skirts
of the Danes, stop dodging away from his Backbenchers, stop this uncertainty
that is doing so much damage to Britain's prospects of recovery. I suggested
that wording to the Prime Minister; he's put it in. If he stands up to that
I'll support him.
DIMBLEBY: You say if he stands up to that. Can
anything between now and the Division Lobbies on Wednesday evening change your
mind and bring about a position where you would NOT support John Major?
ASHDOWN: Jonathan, you should never put, never
under-estimate this Government's capacity to muck things up. If there is a
smell of confidence in the Government about this, if there is any chance
whatsoever of bringing the Government down on Wednesday - because they make the
vote by itself an issue of confidence - of course we shall vote this terrible
Government down, because in doing so I know that we would bring about a General
Election which would get a Government which was more constructive towards
Europe than this one is.
But that is not going to happen - you
know it's not going to happen and it is a deceipt of the Labour Party to
pretend that it is. Because what would happen under those circumstances is
that the Government would put down a vote of no confidence, a vote of
confidence on Thursday - they would win that, and the consequence would be that
we would end up in the worst of all possible worlds. Directly as a result of
the Labour's unprincipled U-turn in this, we'd end up on Friday morning with no
General Election and no future for Britain in Europe either.
DIMBLEBY: But if the Whips, as it is alleged they
are and, as we heard a couple of the Tory Backbenchers there saying, turn this
into a vote of confidence into the Government, according to John Major himself.
Ian Taylor was talking about a vote of confidence. If it is a vote of
confidence in John Major, and is seen to be that by those waverers who would,
with you, determine the outcome, what happens then?
ASHDOWN: Jonathan, let me see if I can step back.
What is the role of an Opposition Party, any Party? It is to put the interests
of the nation before the Westminster game. So let us judge that decision
according to the interests of the nation.
Would the condition of Britain be
improved if John Major was replaced by Kenneth Clarke or anybody else, and we
had a Tory Government, the answer to that is "No". Would the position of
Britain be damaged if Britain didn't have a future IN Europe and was isolated
outside it, the answer to that is "Yes".
So the question is whether or not we can
get a General Election out of Wednesday's vote. If we can, of course we will
vote to bring the Government down. But who is the Leader of a Conservative
Government is to my mind utterly, utterly irrelevant, and I'm certainly not
prepared to put that above Britain's long-term future in Europe.
DIMBLEBY: Are you saying that if what was alleged
to have been said by people close to John Major on that aeroplane from Egypt,
that there would be a General Election if the Prime Minister went down on this
- if they were still sticking to that position, then you would be voting
against.
ASHDOWN: Unquestionably, and this is where the
deceipt of the Labour Party lies. I mean, let's leave aside for one moment
that Jack Cunningham, the Labour Party's Foreign Affairs spokesman, a month ago
was recommending to the French that they should vote in favour of Maastricht
and will now go into the lobbies with his Party next Wednesday voting against
it. Let's leave aside the dishonesty involved in that.
Let us just concentrate on this single
fact. That they know and we know that turkeys do not vote for Christmas. What
will be killed on Wednesday is Britain's future in Europe. The Government will
then return with a vote of confidence on Thursday, which they will win, and
we'll be left with no General Election and no future in Europe.
Labour may be prepared to play fast and
loose with the future of this Country - I will not.
DIMBLEBY: But you're presuming that turkeys don't
vote for Christmas in politics. There is a difference between turkeys and
politicians. Politicians do sometimes vote for Christmas on their principle.
ASHDOWN: Ok. Let's, don't accept my word about
it. Let's take Bill Cash's word. He's the person most adamantly opposed to
the Government. He made it quite clear that if there's a vote of confidence,
which clearly there would be on Thursday, he'd vote for the Government, so what
Labour is doing is involving itself in a dishonesty which I certainly will not
support - it is playing the Westminster game - it is actually now about to say
that the issue here is that the Maastricht Bill should be delayed for four
weeks. Now what happens in those four weeks?
The uncertainty about Britain's future
in Europe continues; our capacity to recover is diminished; more people lose
their jobs - the very people that the Labour Party were campaigning in favour
of in Hyde Park Rally three weeks' ago, two weeks' ago, will be the ones who
suffer if Britain's future is not, does not lie in Europe. I think it is just
about the most tawdry and discreditable act from an Opposition Party that I
have seen in recent years, and I intend to be, and my Party intends to be, no
part of it.
There are times when you stand by your
principles, and this is one.
DIMBLEBY: What would the Foreign Secretary or the
Prime Minister or any other Member of the Cabinet, have to say between now and
that Wednesday night for you to change your mind?
ASHDOWN: I think if the Government make it clear
that if the Bill goes down on Wednesday night there will be a General Election
and Mr. Major will go to the Queen, leaving aside the fact that I think it
would put the Queen in a very difficult Constitutional position. Leaving aside
the Constitutional issues, if the Government make that clear of course we shall
vote to remove this Government - I can't wait for it to go. But I know that
isn't the case; you know that isn't the case; and what is much more
important, the Labour Party, indulging in the deceipt that it is, also knows it
isn't the case.
DIMBLEBY: So Charles Kennedy, when he says we'll
wait and see what they make of it, was suggesting there were a range of subtle
alternatives, is wrong on this? This is no longer the position of the Party?
ASHDOWN: Charles was speaking before we had
consulted amongst colleagues. I now have consulted. They took this view. My
Party is unanimous on it, my MPs are absolutely clear that the interests of the
nation come first and that means making sure that Britain has a future in
Europe. We will vote for this.
I've been pressing the Prime Minister
for months to face up to his Backbenchers. I've been pressing him for months
to stop hiding behind the skirts of the Danes. I've been pressing him for
months to clear up this uncertainty that is extending the recession. If now,
as a result of our pressure, he has finally found the stomach to do that, of
course I'll back him.
DIMBLEBY: Does this mean, insofar as it's
necessary - you suggest it won't be, it's a three-line Whip for all your MPs.
ASHDOWN: We don't have three-line Whips in our
Party in that sense, but all my MPs, all the MPs in the Party - I understand
how some members of the Party are worried about this, I can understand that, I
understand the pressure on them - but at the end of the day we must.......
DIMBLEBY: What are they saying to you?
ASHDOWN: Well, they're saying that we ought to be
voting - very few of them, I mean at the Scottish Conference thirty out of
three hundred took the view - but of course I understand. That's very tough.
Nothing that is good in politics is ever easy, but there are times when you
put the national interest first. There are times when you have - as this Party
has, for forty years, sometimes alone on this issue - stood by its principles.
The Labour Party may have changed twice in every decade, their view on Europe,
but I don't intend to join them, neither do my colleagues.
DIMBLEBY: Are you happy with what might be the
headline if the Government wins - "Paddy Ashdown saves John Major's bacon"?
ASHDOWN: No, I'm happy with the headline which
says "Paddy Ashdown's saved Britain's future in Europe", and I'm delighted with
the headline which says "The Labour Party has turned tail again on this issue".
I don't believe you can win the trust of
the British people by asking them to vote for something in April which you vote
against in November.
DIMBLEBY: So you tell your MPs in the depths of a
recession, when the Government is promising painful spending cuts, don't worry
(in seats where Labour's breathing down your neck), don't worry chaps - you
may lose your seat but you'll have saved us for Europe.
ASHDOWN: There are times when you have to do the
things that are necessary to stand by your principle. This is not the Labour
Party, it never has been. But your question of the economy is absolutely
right. Unless we now resolve the uncertainty over Britain's future in Europe,
we will damage our capacity to get out of this recession and the direct
consequence of Labour's move, if they should succeed and I desperately hope for
the future of this country, they do not, will be that that recession will
continue and more jobs will be lost.
I give you this prediction - if there is
any possibility that Labour wins on Thursday, on Wednesday, I'll bet you the
good Europeans in the Labour Party will turn out not to be there.
DIMBLEBY: Do you believe finally and briefly that
it is too close to call at the moment?
ASHDOWN: Yes, that's why I think the Labour
Party's position is SO discreditable. That's why I think that this deceipt
that they're perpetrating, that the Government could fall that day, which they
know isn't true, is so dishonest, and that's why I believe at the end of it
good Europeans - like John Smith did in 1972, but is now ducking now - good
Europeans in the Labour Party if there's any possibility of Maastricht falling,
will simply not be there.
DIMBLEBY: Paddy Ashdown, thank you very much.
...oooOooo...
|