Join The Debate
Thursday September 4th - LIVE Online forum with Brian Taylor, BBC Scotland's Political Editor.
Put your questions to Brian here, and follow the debate here between 7PM and 8PM BST...
You can also express your opinions by emailing them to us - we will publish a selection of them here.
It is my belief that as a single nation the entire electorate should have the right to express their opinion, devolution of Scotland, Wales, possibly Northern Ireland may lead to other clearly identified areas making the same demands (e.g. Cornwall ) these decisions will have an impact upon all other parts of the union.
Malcolm Chewter
Other critics suggest that devolution will lead to the break-up of the UK.
This will only happen if the people want it to happen. Ireland went straight
from being part of the UK to independence in 1922 without devolution. The
Isle of Man has been under the British Crown since 1765, with its own
legislature, yet shows no sign of wishing to break all remaining ties - such
as defence, currency and foreign affairs.
Yours sincerely,
"West Lothian Question"
albeit that it affects varying parts of the Nation. In the current parliament the South of England still has a very clear Conservative majority with a Labour Government in the same way as Scotland has experienced a Conservative Government for 18 years.
Opponents of devolution produce the so-called West Lothian question, yet fail
to realise that the UK constitution must take into account the extraordinary
diversity within these islands. Scotland has its own legal system, yet does
not currently have its own legislature. The result is that desirable law
reforms proposed by the Scottish Law Commission and others often fail to
reach the statute book. Is Scottish Question Time once a month at Westminster
really sufficient scrutiny?
Matthew Ross
Edinburgh.
