|
Abbott:Blocked for membership?
|
Abbott to Lose Place on Treasury Select Committee
Labour leftwinger Diane Abbott has claimed that she's been blocked for
membership of the powerful Commons Treasury Select Committee because of her
outspoken opposition to Government policy.
The MP for Hackney North and Stoke Newington is expected to be dropped after eight years of service when the committee's membership is announced on Monday night.
Ms Abbot said her criticism of new Labour policies, including Chancellor Gordon Brown's recent decision to give independence to the Bank of England, could have cost her place. "I was the only person who was already on the select committee who wanted to continue who wasn't allowed to continue. I think the main reason was that they thought I was too independent
minded," she said.
Ms Abbott said she had a good record of attendance and performance on the
committee.
But her name will not be among the seven Labour MPs selected for the
committee tonight, who, apart from Giles Radice (Durham N) and Brian Sedgemore
(Hackney S and Shoreditch), have little or no experience of how the Treasury
committee works."To drop somebody from a select committee because they disagree with Government policy makes a nonsense of the idea of independent select
committees," Ms Abbott said.
An Independent View
The committees of backbenchers were set up to scrutinise legislation and to
challenge the Government where they believe it has acted incorrectly. Some MPs are becoming concerned over the replacement of seasoned, independent voices like Ms Abbott by less experienced MPs, who could see the select committees as a springboard for a Government career.
Ms Abbott would not be drawn on this issue, but said "I just felt, as a
point of principle, that members of select committees should make up their
minds about policies on their merit, otherwise you might as well not have the
select committee system." She also refused to be drawn on who was behind her removal from the committee.
New members will include Ruth Kelly, who worked for the Bank of England
before becoming MP for Bolton West, and Putney MP Tony Coleman - one of new
Labour's millionaires.
Not Enough Places to go Round
A Labour source later tried to play down Ms Abbott's claims, saying it was
really a matter of logistics. "We have an additional 140 new Labour MPs. The problems of allocating people to select committees are immense. "As I understand it, Diane Abbott is on the Foreign Affairs select committee and therefore she is on a high profile committee. But it was always going to be a case that many people would be disappointed as there are just not enough places to please everyone."
|